Jessie Taylor is furious when her roommate secretly posts her picture on the dating website LDS Lookup — furious, that is, until she spends all night instant messaging Ben Bratton. Their first date is a smashing success (literally), but Ben’s overall awesomeness can’t save Jessie from having to deal with Craig, her competitive coworker. Jessie spends long office hours finishing projects and putting out fires, but while her performance wows her boss, it only makes Ben skittish— after a failed engagement to an up-and-coming lawyer, he’s not about to pair up with someone who’s married to her job. Will Jessie figure out how to be true to herself and take her big chance at love before it’s gone with a click of the mouse?
Buy Paperback (25% off)
or Kindle Version ($9.99)
Also available:
The List
Not My Type
Chapter 1

The rolled up yoga mat bounced off of my roommate’s head with a satisfying thwack.

“Ow!” Sandy protested. “Are you trying to kill me?”

“Yes. Stay still so I can hit you again.”

She chose to dodge instead, her red hair streaking behind her as she placed the dining table between us as a safety buffer. “I don’t understand why you’re so angry,” she said. “I did it to help you.”

“Did I ask you to help?” I hoped she could hear the annoyance in my voice.

“No. But only because you’re too stubborn. Why can’t you see this as an amazing act of service?”

That stopped my mat-wielding for a moment. “You’re trying to spin this as service? ” I detected her smile trying to break out and scowled.

“You don’t know what’s good for you. But I do, and if you would just drop your weapons and take a look at the computer again, you’ll see that I’m right.”

“I’m not dropping anything,” I said. “I haven’t gotten to use the pillow yet.” I picked the green throw cushion off of the sofa to emphasize my point.

“Trust me, Jessie. Check the computer before you hit me with anything else. They’re not that bad.”

“They?!” I fought a screech. “There’s more than one?”

“Yeah,” she grinned. “You’ve got three matches. Lucky you.” Her tone changed to one of wheedling. “I’m just trying to be a good friend,” she said.

“By signing me up for an Internet dating site without my permission?” I dropped the green pillow to shove a hand through my hair. This situation had gone from irritating to embarrassing now that I knew real live boys had actually looked at the profile she set up. “Tell me truth,” I said. “Are you crazy?”

Sandy did her best to look offended, but I could see the laughter in her eyes. “It's not a dating site.”

“You're not even sorry,” I accused her.

“Nope. You won’t be, either. I promise. Check the screen. If I’m wrong then I’ll drop it, but there’s one guy you have to see.”

I threw the mat and pillow on the sofa and plopped down beside them, giving Sandy’s laptop an impatient tug toward me. My own face stared back at me from the screen, cropped from a snapshot that used to show the two of us together at a barbecue the previous summer. Now it showed only me. Looking pretty good, actually. The website banner over my photo announced, “Meet one of the newest LDS Lookup members!”

“This is humiliating,” I grumbled.

“Why? You look hot in that picture. I put it up two days ago and you’ve already got guys lining up.”

“Wrong. You’ve got guys lining up for me which is a totally different thing.”

“No, it isn’t. I filled out your profile like you would.”

“Like I would? I would never have filled it out. That's why I want to kill you.” I patted the sofa in search of the yoga mat but Sandy whisked it out of my reach.

“Check your profile and tell me if I got anything wrong.”

I scanned it, ignoring her while I read. She listed me as twenty-five, an accountant in the Greater Seattle area, active LDS, and looking for—

“You are so dead!” I yelped. “You can’t put that I'm searching for a relationship on the Internet! It’s pathetic.”

Sandy rolled her eyes. “It’s a social networking site. Over half the people on here are looking for relationships,” she said.

The rest of the profile outlined my likes (comedies, fresh baked bread, being outdoors) and dislikes (heavy metal, mumblers, the Yankees) pretty accurately. I couldn’t find much else to quibble with.

“Why would you do this?” I asked. But I already knew the answer. Her persistence in trying to jump start my social life knew no bounds.

“I’m trying to help you keep your promises,” she said.

I rolled my eyes. “Promises extracted under extreme duress don't count.”

She grinned. The week before she had forced me to make a New Year’s resolution to go out more by hiding my favorite ice cream behind her back until I agreed. I would have left her standing there with a quart of melted Haagen Dazs except she waved a spoonful of butter pecan under my nose and I folded. I promised to leave the condo every once in a while and she gave me my ice cream back. It would be hard. I payed a stiff mortgage so I could stay in my living room whenever I wanted, and I'd spent a lot of time decorating it to make it an inviting space.

“I keep telling you this is for your own good,” she reminded me.

“How come I don’t get to decide what’s for my own good?”

“Because you keep getting it wrong. Your work-to-play ratio is all screwed up.”

“There’s nothing wrong with a good work ethic. You of all people should appreciate that,” I pointed out. Sandy works at the same software company as me, Macrosystems, but in human resources, a sanitized name for the place where they do all the firing when people have bad work ethics. Sandy focused more on recruiting and hiring, but she had no problem dropping the axe when someone deserved it. She’d fired enough people over the last five years to develop bullet-proof skin, which is probably why I could practically see my complaints about her high-handedness bouncing right off of her.

“You don’t have a good work ethic; you have a sickness that compels you to work ridiculous amounts of overtime and waste your weekend on spreadsheets. I’m being a good friend by forcing you to mix it up a little.”

“And stealing my identity for a fake dating site post?” I asked. I wasn’t going down without a fight.

“Excuse me, but I'm the drama queen around here. I will not deposed, so leave the exaggerations to me. It’s not fake, and for the last time, it’s not a dating site. Think Facebook for Mormons.”

“How did you of all people find it?” Although Sandy and I met through a Seattle LDS housing email list, she hadn’t been to church in the whole time I’d known her. I couldn't picture her surfing LDS sites.

“Ah, Google. It’s a wonderful thing. I entered ‘find roommate a hot LDS guy’ and wham! LDS Lookup popped up right at my fingertips.”

“Ha ha.”

“Fine,” she relented. “I checked out a ton of sites before picking this one because it has the coolest vibe. Seriously, check out the guys that sent you messages.”

She yanked her laptop back and clicked the mouse a couple of times. “Look at him. He sent a Love to Know More request.”

As much as I wanted to, I couldn’t resist. The profile showed a guy in maybe his late twenties with blond hair and a nice smile. I scanned through the rest of his bio and snorted. “No way,” I said.

“What? He’s cute. And he seems smart.”

“Yeah, and he listed Charlies Sheen as his personal hero. No, thanks.”

“Look at the other guy. He’s cute, too.” She clicked again and pulled up another profile.

As soon as his link opened, I said, “No.”

“You didn’t even read it!”

“His screen name is I’m4Real. You can’t be real if you use numbers for letters. So, no.”

“What if someone disqualified you as a prospect because of your screen name?”

Cue panic. “What is my screen name?”

“Sugar.”

My eyes widened in horror.

She grinned. “I’m kidding. I put your initials. That’s fine, right?”

“I guess. Let's get this over with. Show me the last one.”

She shrugged. “If you didn’t like the first two, I don’t think the last one is going to do it for you,” she said. But she pulled it up anyway.

“Lame profile?” I asked.

“I didn’t read it. He's not as cute as the other two.”

I opened his profile. His screen name said Harold Crick. How do you know if he's cute or not?” I couldn't tell much from the picture since it wasn’t a close up, but I caught the glint of glasses, and his dark, floppy hair appealed to me.

“I’m not into guys with glasses. Besides,” she said, peering over my shoulder, “what kind of name is Harold Crick? He didn’t even put a screen name.”

“Yes, he did. Harold Crick is a character.” The main character in one of my favorite movies, Stranger Than Fiction, as a matter of fact.

“Whatever. Does he say anything good?”

I read through, going as slowly as possible to annoy Sandy. She only angled the screen so she could read over my shoulder. It took her all of five seconds to protest, “No way, Jessie. He’s a lumberjack!”

“He works for the forestry service. That doesn’t make him a lumberjack.”

“You want to put money on that?” Sandy challenged me. “I don’t know a lot about online dating but I know you have to read between the lines. Lives within a fifty mile radius, works for the forestry service, and loves the outdoors. This guy is totally holed up in a cabin at the foot of Mt. Rainier, shivering in his moth-eaten flannels and waiting for a pretty lady to come keep him warm.” She started singing an off-key version of Monty Python’s lumberjack song. “He’s a lumberjack—aack.” She ducked the green throw pillow.

“Don’t sing.”

She shifted and batted the pillow to the floor.

“He doesn’t sound so bad,” I said. “Cool movie choices, cool bands, and he listed some books. That he read. I bet Mr. I’m4Real has an impressive comic book collection instead.”

“Yeah, but he’s cuter.”

“Well, that’s more important, then.”

“I’m just saying, you should start with someone good-looking right out of the gate.”

“But this Harold Crick guy’s picture is blurry, so maybe he’s cuter.”

“Or maybe it’s blurry because he’s not and he’s trying to fool you.”

“You’re right,” I said. “Online dating is stupid. Thanks for talking me out of it.” I pushed the computer aside and made to get off of the couch.

“Wait! Online dating is a great idea. No, really,” she said in response to my skeptical expression. “Oprah talked about it in her life class. It’s working for people.” Sandy missed seeing Oprah on her DVR so much that she periodically signed up for her online seminars.

I said nothing.

She switched to a guilt trip. “When was your last date, Jessie?”

I stubbornly didn’t answer.

“Do you even remember?” she pressed.

“LDS guys aren’t falling out of trees around here,” I said.

“I know that. But you used to go out all the time and now you never do. You work way too much. You’re going to burn out and either quit or get fired, but either way I’ll have to hire someone new. It’s so much extra work for me.”

She tried to look pitiful. “If you won’t do it for you, can’t you do it as a favor to me? You know, have a little fun so I don’t have to do extra paperwork?”

“That’s the lamest reason I’ve ever heard,” I said.

She continued to look pitiful.

I sighed. “Where’s Harold Crick?”